兩個WEB自動化測試工具比較 WatiN & Selenium RC
|
Item |
WatiN |
Selenium RC |
|
Explorer Supported |
Known work
Ø IE 6 and IE 7 |
Known work
Ø IE 6 and IE 7
Ø Firefox 1.5.0 and 2.0
Ø Opera 8.5.4 and 9.0.2
Should work
Ø Firefox 0.8 to 2.0
Ø Mozilla Suite 1.6+, 1.7+
Ø Sea monkey 1.0 |
|
System supported |
Known work
Ø Windows XP and 2003 |
Known work
Ø Windows XP and 2003
Ø Windows 2000(need to install install reg.exein order to use IE)
Ø Mac OS X
Ø Linux |
|
Language supported |
Ø C# |
Ø C#
Ø Java
Ø Perl
Ø PHP
Ø Python
Ø Ruby |
|
Test environment supported |
Ø Visual Studio 2005 Team System |
Ø Visual Studio 2005 Team System |
|
AJAX |
Supports AJAX website testing |
l Selenium Server communicates directly with the browser using AJAX (XmlHttpRequest)
l The Selenium Server is great for testing complex AJAX-based web user interfaces under a Continuous Integration system |
|
Get/Post requests |
|
We can send commands directly to the Server using simple HTTP GET/POST requests |
|
Https supported |
|
Support for https |
|
Javascrīpt Supported |
Void Document.Runscrīpt(string) |
l We can write selenium RC tests in Javascrīpt with JsUnit.
l it Allows a Selenium-enabled browser to run Javascrīpt on arbitrary websites. |
|
HTML |
Automates all major HTML elements and find elements by multiple attributes |
|
|
HTML dialogs |
Supports HTML dialogs (modal and modeless) |
|
|
Frame |
Supports frame (Cross domain) and iframes |
|
|
Popup dialogs |
Supports popup dialogs like alert, confirm, login etc |
|
|
Screenshots |
Support creating screenshots of web pages |
|
|
|
|
對現有控件的兼容性不好。比如文件上傳控件和日曆控件就無法在Selenium RC中捕捉
2.不支持https連接方式？？ http://bbs.51testing.com/thread-84131-1-6.html |
Developing Info
|
Item |
WatiN |
Selenium RC |
|
Developing Language |
Ø C# |
Ø Java and so on |
Methods Example
|
Item |
WatiN Example |
Selenium RC Example |
|
Set element
event |
Document.button(Find.ById(btnG”)).click() |
DefaultSelenium.Type(“q”,”hello world”) |
|
Get element attributes |
Document.button (Find.ById(btnG”)).Style. Height |
DefaultSelenium.GetElementHeight(“q”) |
|
especial methods |
Then we can’t hanle the time used for pages loading.
===》
Ø Link[1].Click()
Ø Link(Find.ByIndex(1)).Click()
We can use these two methods to click the links that the value is null. |
Ø WaitForPageToLoad(“5000”)
(if we want to go to another page and get the elements in the new page, we have to use the method, or we will in the old page.)
《== We can’t find the links that the value is null |